Chapter 1: Before/After

Lee Harding was twenty-two years old and he was looking at a man who didn’t exist.

The man had traps that rose from his shoulders like geography. His chest had a separation down the middle that caught shadow. His arms, even relaxed, suggested something deliberate and complete. In the caption he said he’d been training for three years and eating clean. In the comments, someone asked about his programme and he’d posted a PDF for £29.99.

Lee scrolled past him. The next one was similar. Then the next.

It was half eleven on a Tuesday night and he’d been on his phone since he got home from the warehouse at nine, still in his work clothes, sitting on the edge of his bed in his flat in Beeston. The flat was a one-bedroom on a terrace that backed onto a car park. At this hour the street noise had mostly settled to a low hum - the occasional bus on the main road, someone’s television through the wall, a dog barking in the distance. His work clothes smelled of the warehouse: forklift diesel, cardboard dust, the synthetic warmth of a heated building. He should have showered. He scrolled instead.

The algorithm had learned him over two years of daily use and now it delivered exactly what it knew he wanted, which was also the thing that made him feel worst about himself. He understood the mechanics of it. He’d read the articles. He scrolled anyway.

He stopped on a before/after. Two photos side by side - same man, eighteen months apart. On the left he was soft, self-conscious, arms slightly away from his body in the way people stand when they don’t want to take up space. On the right he was different in a way that went beyond the muscle. He was standing differently. Looking at the camera like he’d decided something.

Consistency is the only secret, the caption said. No shortcuts. Just showing up every day.

Lee read it twice. Then he went to the man’s profile and scrolled back eighteen months to find the beginning.

---

He’d been training for two years himself. Started at twenty when a girl he’d been seeing for eight months told him she’d been seeing someone else for three of them, and he needed something to do with the evenings that wasn’t sitting in his flat thinking about it. His mate Jordan knew someone who worked the desk at a gym on Dewsbury Road, got him a cheap membership, and Lee had shown up three times a week for the first month purely out of stubbornness.

The first session Jordan had come with him. This was in February, a grey Tuesday, and the gym had the low-ceilinged, slightly damp quality of every gym in a converted industrial unit - rubber floor, strip lighting, the clang of free weights echoing off bare walls. Jordan had stood at the edge of the squat rack with his arms folded, watching Lee attempt to work out where to start.

“Bar’s twenty kilos,” Jordan said. “Start with just the bar.”

“I know that.”

“You looked like you didn’t know that.”

Lee had loaded on a couple of tens anyway and tried to squat it and got about halfway down before something in his hips said no and he had to stand back up. Jordan had not been diplomatic about this.

“Give over,” Jordan said, taking the tens off. “Technique first. You’re not impressing anyone.”

He wasn’t. There was nobody to impress. The gym at seven PM was mostly older men who’d been coming for years and paid no attention to anything except what was directly in front of them. Lee had squatted an empty bar for twenty minutes while Jordan timed his rests and told him to keep his chest up, and he’d driven home aching in muscles he hadn’t known were there, and he’d come back on Thursday.

Then something shifted.

He was good at it. Not naturally — he’d been the skinny kid at school in Hunslet, the one the PE teacher didn’t bother with, built like a question mark and about as useful in a scrum. But in the gym he found that if he paid attention, if he actually learned what he was doing rather than just picking things up and putting them down, he improved. Consistently. Week after week. He read about programming and progressive overload and nutrition. He tracked his lifts in a notes app. He stopped going out on Friday nights because he trained Saturday mornings and he wanted to mean it.

By the end of year one he’d put on almost a stone of muscle. People at work noticed. His mum said he looked well. A girl on the tram home looked at him in a way she wouldn’t have looked at him before, and he’d spent the rest of the journey trying to work out if he’d imagined it. When he’d deliberately sat across from her the next week and she’d held his gaze for longer than was accidental, he’d known he hadn’t.

He hadn’t imagined it. The body counted as evidence that he was becoming someone different. He hadn’t known he was waiting for that kind of evidence until he got it.

Year two he got more serious. Trained five days. Ate more protein than he’d previously thought was possible. Cooked chicken and rice in industrial quantities. Made mental calculations about macros. Took creatine, which worked, and a dozen other supplements, which mostly didn’t but he bought anyway because the guys online swore by them. He watched YouTube for hours—form breakdowns, programme reviews, natural bodybuilders explaining their approach. He got good at spotting the ones who weren’t natural. The proportions that didn’t add up. The conditioning that arrived too fast. The traps and shoulders that grew at a rate two years of lifting can’t actually produce. The way their shape looked different in a way he couldn’t quite name but could feel.

He knew. He’d watched enough to know exactly what he was looking at when he saw it. He told himself he was better than that. More disciplined. More willing to wait. More real.

He was, genuinely, in decent shape. His arms were real. His back was real. He’d earned it. If you put him next to the man he was at twenty he’d look like a different person.

But the algorithm didn’t show him that version. It showed him the man he wasn’t yet.